How to Buy Premium Extra Virgin Olive Oil in the UK
Updated: Oct 25
Supermarket shelves are full of bottles labelled "extra virgin", at prices from £4 to £40. So how do you tell a genuinely premium olive oil from a bland one? It mostly comes down to reading the label and knowing what to look for.
1. Make sure it says "extra virgin"
Extra virgin is the highest grade of olive oil. It is obtained directly from olives and solely by mechanical means, and it must pass laboratory tests and a tasting panel. "Olive oil", "pure olive oil" and "light olive oil" are lower grades that include refined oil, which removes most of the flavour and natural polyphenols.
2. Check the acidity
By law, extra virgin olive oil must have an acidity of no more than 0.8%. The best oils are far lower. Low acidity is a sign of healthy fruit that was handled and pressed quickly. Many brands don't print it, so a stated figure is a good sign. Our Early Harvest and Master Miller both have an acidity of 0.2%.
3. Look for a single country of origin
The label must say where the oil comes from. "Blend of EU oils" or "blend of EU and non-EU oils" means the oil may come from several countries. A single named country, such as Spain, tells you more about what you are buying.
4. Check the best before date
Olive oil is best fresh. Choose a bottle with a best before date well into the future and buy what you will use in a few months, rather than a large tin that sits open for a year.
5. Choose dark glass or a tin
Light, heat and air are what make olive oil go stale. Dark glass or tins protect it. Avoid clear bottles kept under bright shop lights.
6. Look for polyphenols and early harvest
Polyphenols are natural plant compounds that give fresh olive oil its bitterness and peppery finish. Oils made from olives picked early, while still green, are naturally richer in them. Some producers state a polyphenol figure in mg/kg; ours is over 500 mg/kg for our Early Harvest and over 400 mg/kg for Master Miller.
7. Check organic certification
An organic olive oil sold in the UK should show the EU or UK organic logo and the code of its organic control body.
8. Taste it
A good extra virgin olive oil smells fresh: cut grass, green apple, tomato leaf or almond. It should taste fruity, with some bitterness and a peppery catch at the back of the throat. Flat, greasy or musty flavours are signs of a poor or old oil.
What should premium olive oil cost?
Good extra virgin olive oil costs more because early harvest olives give less oil and careful production takes time. As a rough guide, expect to pay more than you would for everyday supermarket oil, and judge it on the label checks above rather than the price alone.
Buying online in the UK
When you buy online, check where the oil is dispatched from and what delivery costs. Our oils are dispatched from Lytham St Annes within 24 hours (Monday to Friday), delivered in 1–4 working days, with free UK delivery on orders of £50 or more.
Frequently asked questions
What is the best olive oil to buy in the UK?
Look for extra virgin olive oil from a single country, with a low stated acidity, a best before date well ahead, dark glass and a fresh, peppery taste.
Is expensive olive oil worth it?
Price alone doesn't guarantee quality. Use the label: grade, acidity, origin, date and polyphenols tell you far more.
What does "cold-extracted" mean?
It means the oil was made without heat. Most modern mills use a centrifuge, so "cold extraction" is the correct term; "first cold pressed" applies only to traditional presses.
How should I store olive oil once opened?
In a cool, dark cupboard away from the cooker, with the cap closed. Use it within 6–8 weeks of opening for the freshest flavour.




Comments