top of page

Why Does Good Olive Oil Cost More? What You're Paying For

7 days ago
2 min read

Good extra virgin olive oil costs more because it takes more olives, more care and more time to make, and because it has to reach you fresh. Most of the price gap between a premium oil and a cheap one comes from harvest timing, yield and quality control.

What drives the price

  • Harvest timing. Early harvest olives are picked green, when they hold much less oil. It can take considerably more olives to make a litre of early harvest oil than of late harvest oil.

  • Speed to the mill. Milling within hours of picking, as we do with our Early Harvest (within 4 hours), means more trips and smaller batches.

  • Cold extraction. Keeping the paste below 27°C protects flavour and polyphenols but gives a lower yield.

  • Testing. Lab tests for acidity, peroxides and polyphenols, plus tasting panels, cost money every batch.

  • Organic certification. Organic groves are inspected and certified each year, and yields are often lower.

  • Packaging. Dark glass and tins cost more than clear plastic, but protect the oil from light.

  • Climate. Droughts in Spain in 2022 and 2023 roughly halved harvests and pushed world prices to record highs. Prices fell back as harvests recovered, but weather still sets the baseline every year.

Why is some olive oil so cheap?

Cheaper oils are often blends from several countries, from later harvests, or from older stock. Lower grades such as "olive oil" or "light" are partly refined. None of this is unsafe, but it is a different product from a fresh, single-origin extra virgin.

Is expensive olive oil worth it?

It is worth it if you will taste it. For drizzling, dressings and dipping, a fresh, high-quality oil makes an obvious difference. For deep frying large quantities, a good everyday extra virgin is enough.

A sensible approach is two bottles: a premium oil for finishing and an everyday one for cooking. See How to Buy Premium Extra Virgin Olive Oil in the UK.

How to check you're getting value

  1. Extra virgin on the label

  2. A harvest date, ideally this season's

  3. A single country of origin

  4. A stated acidity, and ideally a polyphenol figure

  5. Dark glass or a tin

Our prices

Our organic Early Harvest costs £19.99 for 500ml and Master Miller £18.99 for 500ml, with free UK delivery on orders over £50.

Frequently asked questions

Does price guarantee quality?

No. Use the label checks above. A high price with no harvest date or origin is a warning sign.

Why do olive oil prices change every year?

Olive oil is an agricultural product. Drought, heat and frost change harvest size, which changes prices.

Is VAT charged on olive oil in the UK?

Olive oil is a food and is normally zero-rated for VAT in the UK.

Comments


bottom of page