top of page

Olive Oil Tasting Notes: A Glossary of Flavours and Faults

5 days ago
2 min read

Professional tasters judge olive oil on three positive qualities: fruitiness, bitterness and pungency (pepperiness). A good extra virgin olive oil has some fruitiness and no faults. Everything else on a tasting note describes the kind of fruitiness, or a fault that disqualifies the oil.

The three positive attributes

  • Fruity: aromas of fresh, healthy olives. Can be "green fruity" (grass, leaf, unripe fruit) or "ripe fruity" (softer, riper fruit).

  • Bitter: felt on the tongue, especially at the back. Typical of oil from green olives and a sign of polyphenols.

  • Pungent: the peppery catch in the throat that can make you cough. Also linked to polyphenols, especially oleocanthal.

Common flavour notes

  • Cut grass: fresh, green, typical of early harvest oils

  • Tomato leaf or tomato vine: common in Spanish oils from Picual and Cornicabra

  • Artichoke: green and slightly bitter

  • Green apple: crisp and fresh, often in Arbequina

  • Almond: soft and nutty, often in the finish

  • Green banana: a fruity note found in many fresh oils

  • Herbs: basil, mint or fennel-like freshness

Common faults

Any of these means the oil is not extra virgin:

  • Rancid: smells of stale nuts, crayons or old putty. The oil has oxidised.

  • Fusty: sweaty or muddy, from olives left piled up before milling.

  • Musty: mouldy or damp, from olives stored in humid conditions.

  • Winey or vinegary: sour, from fermentation.

  • Muddy sediment: from oil left too long on its sediment.

  • Metallic: from contact with metal surfaces during processing.

How to use this

Taste a little oil on its own from a small glass. Smell first, then sip and breathe in through your teeth. Our step-by-step guide is How to Taste Olive Oil Like a Pro.

Our Early Harvest has notes of green grass, tomato leaf, almond and green banana, with balanced bitterness and a peppery finish.

Frequently asked questions

Is bitter olive oil bad?

No. Some bitterness is a positive sign, especially in early harvest oil.

What does rancid olive oil smell like?

Like crayons, stale nuts or putty. It's safe but past its best.

Why does good olive oil make me cough?

That is pungency, from natural polyphenols such as oleocanthal. See What Is Oleocanthal?

Comments


bottom of page