top of page

How to Replace Butter with Olive Oil in Baking

Nov 8
2 min read

To replace butter with olive oil in baking, use about three quarters of the amount. So 100g of butter becomes 75g (about 80ml) of olive oil. Butter is roughly 80% fat and the rest is mostly water, while olive oil is 100% fat, which is why you need less.

Butter to olive oil conversions

  • 25g butter → 19g olive oil (about 1½ tbsp)

  • 50g butter → 38g olive oil (about 3 tbsp)

  • 100g butter → 75g olive oil (about 80ml)

  • 125g butter → 94g olive oil (about 100ml)

  • 175g butter → 130g olive oil (about 140ml)

  • 225g butter → 170g olive oil (about 180ml)

Where the swap works best

Olive oil suits bakes where butter is melted, not creamed:

  • Loaf cakes and citrus cakes

  • Muffins and banana bread

  • Brownies (a fruity oil goes well with dark chocolate)

  • Focaccia, flatbreads and savoury scones

  • Carrot cake and courgette cake

These bakes come out moist and keep well, because oil stays liquid at room temperature.

Where it doesn't work

Avoid swapping in recipes that rely on solid butter:

  • Shortbread, pastry and croissants, which need cold, solid fat for flakiness

  • Recipes that cream butter and sugar to trap air, such as a classic Victoria sponge

  • Buttercream and other frostings

Which olive oil to bake with

For sweet bakes, choose a milder oil such as Master Miller. Very peppery oils can dominate delicate cakes, though they're lovely with chocolate, orange or rosemary. For savoury bakes, try a flavoured oil: garlic for focaccia or lemon for a drizzle cake.

Tips for success

  1. Whisk the oil with the eggs and sugar until slightly thickened before adding flour.

  2. Grease tins with olive oil too.

  3. Expect a slightly denser, moister crumb than with butter.

Frequently asked questions

Can I use extra virgin olive oil in cakes?

Yes. It is used in many traditional Mediterranean cakes. Choose a milder one if you don't want the flavour to show.

Does olive oil change the taste of baking?

A little. Mild oils are barely noticeable; fruity oils add a pleasant, slightly peppery note.

Is the swap the same for margarine?

Roughly yes. Most margarines and spreads are 60 to 80% fat, so use a little less oil than the weight of spread.

Comments


bottom of page